He’s not entirely sure when it happened. After all, he had been home for Christmas a mere six months ago and she had still been just his little sister’s friend. He looked at her in the same light, as he had always seen her. Young, innocent, a little annoying the way she used to follow him around like his own shadow. Stella had been best friends with her since preschool and the two of them had been pains in his ass ever since. How many hours had he been left in charge of them during sleepovers and playdates? How many times had he been deemed chauffeur and chaperone over the years? He always did it with a smile on his face, even if he found them to be typical, annoying little girls. He would never admit it, but he didn’t mind big-brother duty that much.
Now they had just finished their senior year of high school. It was why Simon had come home for the summer. One last chance to spend some time with his baby sister before she started her life. She was moving to southern California for college, but Camila was off to Boston where she’d been accepted into MIT, to nobody’s surprise. This meant the girls were on a mission to spend as much time together as they possibly could. That’s how Simon found himself spending a long weekend at the Anderson family cabin surrounded by newly minted high school graduates who had come to swim and sunbathe.
It seemed silly to him. Both Stella and Camila were a week past their 18th birthdays. They hardly needed Simon to babysit them, but Graham, Delilah, and Caitlyn had been adamant so here he was. As it turned out, his presence was needed after all - he’d had to put the kibosh on a rather rowdy situation on the third night when a group of boys from the local college had shown up with beer and caused a scene. Simon had put on his growly grown-up voice and put the fear of God into them until they took off, and the rest of the guests had quickly followed suit. It left Stella glaring at him with her arms crossed when he shut the door on the last of the troublemakers.
“You’re such a dick, Si!” she’d yelled, accenting it with a foot stomp before storming off to her room and slamming the door for emphasis. Simon pinched the bridge of his nose and sighed before heading to the game room to begin cleaning up the mess the partygoers had made.
“Need a hand?” came a voice from behind him about ten minutes into his mission. He turned to see Camila watching him with a shy smile on her face. Simon shrugged and she started picking up cans and bottles, tossing them into the bag he held. “Sorry about that. I think the Facebook event got made public by accident,” she explained.
“It happens,” he said. “Stella can just be such a brat sometimes.” Camila chuckled softly and nodded her agreement as she fluffed the pillows on the couch.
“I think she’s really taking it hard,” she said thoughtfully, righting the books on a shelf that had been tipped over. “Me deciding to go to Boston, I mean.” Simon gave her a sympathetic smile.
“You’ve been best friends for fifteen years. I get it.”
“Yeah,” Camila sighed, sinking down onto the sofa. Simon crossed to her and sat down beside her. They hadn’t spent a ton of time by themselves over the years, but Camila being an only child meant she’d taken a shining to Simon early on. It wasn’t uncommon for the two of them to end up chatting or watching a movie together long after Stella had gone to bed. They shared a unique friendship and Simon had always enjoyed her company. She had always been so much more mature and focused than his sister, but the two of them were a perfect pair. Camila inspired Stella to work hard and do better in school and Stella helped Camila loosen up and have fun once in a while.
“Are you excited?” he asked her. “New city, new friends, new life?” Camila nodded and tucked a strand of blonde hair behind her ear.
“Nervous,” she admitted. “But yeah, excited too. I’ve always wanted to go to school at MIT and now I get to. All my hard work paid off.” Simon beamed proudly at her.
“I always knew it would,” he told her. “What do you have to be nervous about? You’ll do great!” Camila blushed a light shade of pink and bit her lip.
“I’m not worried about school at all, I just…I spent so much time studying and working in high school that I never really had much time for a social life and I—“ she cut herself off and shook her head like she’d decided against explaining herself. Simon tilted his head at her and put a supportive hand on her back. She looked up at him and cleared her throat. “Sorry, it’s dumb.”
“You can always talk to me,” he insisted.
“I’m nervous because,” she tried again, and then she dropped her voice to a whisper before continuing. “I never got around to dating anyone and now I’m going off to college and I’m sure I’m going to be this dorky, awkward virgin whose never been kissed and - ugh—“ she closed her eyes tightly and covered her face with her hands. “Oh God, I can’t believe I just told you that.” Simon chuckled in amusement at her confession.
“You’ve never been kissed?” he asked incredulously. He couldn’t understand why. It’s not as if he’d ever had the urge to kiss her, but again, she’d been nothing more than Stella’s nerdy friend. He had to admit, however, that seeing her all weekend in a bikini with her glasses off and her usually pulled-back hair down in waves had awakened feelings he’d never expected to have for someone like her.
“No,” Camila said, sounding absolutely mortified. “I know it’s so stupid. I just never really went to parties or put myself out there, you know? I’m not Stella. I’m not as outgoing as she is or as confident. I’m not as pretty as she is - “
“That’s ridiculous,” Simon interrupted. “You’re beautiful.” The words were out of his mouth before he even realized he’d said them, and it caught them both off guard. Camila looked absolutely stricken as she gaped at him.
“You - you really think so?” she asked. Simon shrugged, feeling a bit embarrassed for saying such a thing aloud.
“I mean, yeah…You’re cute.” It sounded lame even to his own ears and he could see Camila begin to spiral into self-doubt again, so he doubled down. “You are. And I can’t believe you’ve never been kissed,” he added, and Camila blushed a deep pink that he noticed matched her lips. And since when did he notice her lips? What was that about?
“Well, I haven’t,” she said. “And now I have to go off to college with absolutely zero experience and what happens when a boy tries to kiss me, and I just sit there like a dead fish? Like - where do my hands go? How do I breathe? What do I do with my tongue? Why do people even want someone else’s tongue in their mouth anyway because honestly that just sounds like an invitation for all kinds of illnesses but if I don’t is he going to think I’m an idiot or - “
Simon couldn’t give an excuse for why he did it, except that her babbling was a bit overwhelming, and he needed it to stop. All he knew was that suddenly his lips were on hers and she was frozen. The kiss was timid and gentle and eventually, he felt her melt into it, feeling a small surge of pride when she sighed out a sweet, adorable little moan before she pulled back just slightly. He gave her one, then two lingering pecks before touching his nose to hers and held back a chuckle at the look on her face when they parted.
“There,” he said simply. “That wasn’t so scary, was it?” Camila didn’t answer, but he noted the way she pulled her bottom lip between her teeth and realized he’d very much like to do the same.
“You kissed me,” she said, blinking. Simon nodded, absently running his tongue over his lips. He could still taste her there, and it didn’t escape him the way she tracked his tongue with her eyes as she added, “Can you do it again? I wasn’t ready.”
Simon fought the amused grin spreading over his face. Had she always been this adorable? Camila pushed her glasses up her nose and explained,
“I just didn’t get to practice hand placement, is all.” He didn’t even try to hide his chuckle that time. Instead, he reached for her hands and moved them, placing one on his neck and the other against his chest, holding it in place with one of his own hands. His free hand moved to cup her cheek and he had to suppress yet another laugh at how intent and focused she was on his every move. She was studying him (Of course she was. She hadn’t gotten her scholarship to MIT by not being a studious, fast learner).
When he saw her eyes dart back to his lips, he leaned in, leaving just a breath of space between them and allowing her to close the gap, meeting him where he was. At first, she was hesitant. Her fingers on his neck were nervously stroking the hair there, and he slid his own hand into her hair, pulling her closer and deepening the kiss. She made the sweet little moaning sound again, much to his delight. Even better, the hand on his chest was gripping his shirt and the one on his neck was now pulling him closer.
He ran his tongue experimentally along the seam of her lips and she accepted his invitation, letting her own dance with his. Something about that suddenly emboldened her, and out of nowhere she had pulled him down on top of her, so they were both lying on the couch, Simon cradled between her thighs. It was about the moment that her hips started to undulate beneath him that the sweet, innocent girl he’d only meant to help with a little confidence boost suddenly became an irresistible woman he needed like air.
“Jesus, Camila,” he groaned as she arched beneath him. He pulled back for a moment to look at her - her hair was a mess, and her lips were deliciously swollen.
“I’m sorry,” she gasped, scrambling to move out from under him. “I didn’t - was that—“
“Hey, it’s okay,” he said soothingly. “I just don’t want to - “
“I do,” she interrupted. Simon stared down at her, his mouth agape. He stole a glance at the door, considering the consequences of his sister finding them like this. “Simon?” Camila prodded, pulling him from his thoughts. He looked back down at her, taking in the way his stubble had left little red burns on her skin and the way her chest was heaving from the way he’d kissed the breath out of her. Who cared what Stella thought anyway?
Simon put his weight on his forearms and leaned down to capture her mouth again, soaking in the sounds she made when he experimentally thrust against her. If she’d never been kissed, she’d certainly never done any of this before either, and while he didn’t want to push her past her comfort zone, she was the one who had begun the search for friction. Who was he to deny her?
His khaki shorts were the only substantial barrier between them since she was wearing a light summer dress, the skirt of which was hiked up around her hips, and the feel of her underneath him was enough to make his eyes roll back. She seemed to be enjoying herself just as much if her little gasps and pants were any indication. Simon trailed his lips over her jaw and down her neck, the new sensation causing her to arch up against him again.
“Simon,” she sighed, and he stilled his hips.
“You, okay?” he asked. She nodded breathlessly and wrapped one leg around his waist to pull him even closer to her, causing him to hiss in pleasure. “Tell me if it’s too much. I want to respect you,” he said with the utmost sincerity. Camila rolled her eyes.
“I’ll tell you when you’re not respecting me,” she insisted. He chuckled at that, raising an eyebrow at her. “Seriously,” she told him. “I don’t think it’s any secret that I’ve totally had a crush on you since I was about twelve.”
“Oh, I knew,” he teased her, and she flushed an even brighter shade of pink. “But still, I don’t want you to get ahead of yourself here.” Camila pushed herself up on her elbows to look at him, regarding him with a bit of annoyance and indignation.
“I’m not a little girl, Simon.”
“I know that I just—“
“So, I will decide for myself what is too far, thank you very much.” Her tone was firm, her voice a bit dark and husky with arousal and it went straight to his dick.
God damn it when did she become sexy?
Her usually sky-blue eyes were dark as she stared up at him and just like that his self-control is gone. He pressed a sloppy kiss to her lips and then continued on the trail he’d begun earlier. Back down her jaw and neck, across her collarbone, and then back up the other side. All the while she sang his praises, her fingers twisting in his hair to pull him back up to her mouth.
When they met again, their tongues began the battle for dominance (so much for her fear of that, he thinks to himself when she forces her way into his mouth) as their hips began to roll again.
It was no secret to anyone that Simon was rather experienced in the art of physical affection. His first kiss was in kindergarten under the slide on the playground. He had made out with a girl for the first time at his seventh-grade dance. He had mastered the art of dry humping by age fifteen. And now, as a second-year senior in college, it had been quite awhile since he had kissed someone like this without it spiraling very quickly into something else.
Not tonight, he thought to himself. No matter what Camila said she was ready for, the idea of sleeping with his sister’s best friend - of being her first - was too much for him. But that didn’t mean there weren’t other, more innocent ways of having fun. He shifted, pressing himself against her in just the right way. Her mouth fell open on a moan and she bucked against him even harder.
“Oh my God,” she cried, and her hands flew to his waist, her fingernails digging into his bare skin where his shirt was riding up. “Simon, please.”
He pressed his forehead to her shoulder and thrust against her again and again, drawing out more moans and gasps and pleas for more, harder, please. The wetness of her arousal soaked through her panties, letting him feel just how ready she was as it left a stain on his shorts. He couldn’t even bring himself to care about the mess, all he could do was focus on her.
“Camila,” he whispered harshly against her ear. “I want to see you come for me.”
That was all the encouragement she needed, apparently. She went stiff as her pleasure peaked - her body shuddered against him, her back arching as her mouth fell open on a silent cry. He continued his movements, drawing the orgasm out of her and prolonging it, riding the aftershocks with her. Ever so slowly her breathing returned to normal, but Simon had been right there on the edge with her, and he couldn’t seem to stop himself. He didn’t want to stop himself.
“Oh, wow…” she breathed out, almost reverently like she was completely overwhelmed by the feelings he was making her feel.
It was the sudden realization that he was the first person to share in this with her - the first person to make her come - that made him lose control. The thought brought on a painful, overwhelming wave of arousal and it was all it took to bring him over the edge. He chuckled as he came down - it had been years since he’d come in his pants during a makeout session - and it didn’t escape Camila’s attention.
“Did you just - ?” she asked, trying to sit up. Simon buried his face in her neck and hummed his affirmation. “Oh, wow,” she repeated.
“I’m definitely going to need to clean this up,” he mumbled, moving so he could rest his head on her chest. Her heart was beating quickly, as though she had just run a marathon, but it began to even out as they rested there together. His eyes fluttered closed as her fingers began to card through his hair affectionately. “And we should probably not mention this to Stella.”
“Oh my God - she would kill us,” Camila whispered in horror.
“Mmmhmm,” Simon agreed.
“It was nice though,” she added meekly, bringing a dopey grin to Simon’s face. “Maybe we can have another lesson later?” Simon didn’t reply, but the idea certainly sounded tempting. He let his hand trail down Camila’s side and come to rest on her waist where her dress had ridden up. The skin there was so smooth and pale, and he had an overwhelming urge to taste her.
“Definitely later.”